|
EVA vs. Dexis
|
|
EVA |
Dexis |
Who’s Better? |
Sensor Technology |
CMOS |
CCD |
EVA sensor made from one substrate and imaging chip, Dexis sensor is actually two chips bonded
together and will degrade over time |
|
Connection to computer |
USB |
USB or PCMCIA |
PCMCIA is quickly becoming outdated and has many small pins that can bend or break |
|
Compatible Practice Management Software |
Over 20 major programs |
Eaglesoft, Practiceworks, Softdent, 10 others |
Much more flexibility with EVA |
|
Sensor #1 Dimensions |
24 x 36 x 4.75 mm |
The company does not release the specs of their sensor size,
inspection reveals it to be slightly larger than a #1 film and about 8 mm thick at its thickest point. |
Dexis’ one-size design significantly limits flexibility and may require another 4-6 xrays
to take an FMX. It’s too large for many children and too small to effectively
take a crown to apex shot. |
|
Sensor #1 Active Area |
20 x 30 mm |
|
|
Sensor #2 Dimensions |
30 x 42 x 4.75 mm |
|
|
Sensor #2 Active Area |
26 x 36 mm |
32 x 25.6 (“Universal”) |
|
Sensor Resolution |
16.6 lp/mm actual and theoretical |
25lp/mm* (theoretical)
12.5-18 lp/mm (actual) |
|
Positioning Method |
RINN Set with reusable sterilizable holders |
RINN Set with reusable sterilizable holders |
Identical |
|
Suggested Retail Prices: |
|
|
|
|
Complete System |
$7200 |
$13995 |
|
|
Sensor |
$6200 |
Unknown |
|
|
Docking Station |
$140 |
$179-399 |
|
RINN Holder Set |
$100 |
Unknown |
|
Sheaths |
$60/box 425 pieces |
Unknown |
|
Software |
Included, no charge for additional modules |
Included, optional modules from $1995-$2495 additional |
|
Practice Management Bridge |
$995 |
$495 |
|
Training |
Included |
Included |
|
Installation |
Included |
$1295 minimum |
|
Compatibility with third-party software for future flexibility |
Apteryx, TigerView, Mediadent, DentalEye, ADSTRA, ImageFX |
None |
|
Standard Warranty |
3 years |
1 year |
|
|
Extended Warranty, 1 year |
N/A |
$1995 1st sensor (DexCare)
$1795 2nd sensor (DexCare)
$1295 3rd sensor (DexCare)
$1495 1st sensor (Basic)
$1295 2nd sensor (Basic)
$795 3rd sensor (Basic) |
|
|
Extended Warranty, 2 years |
N/.A |
Double the costs above |
|
Sources: Dentistry Today Buyer’s Guide May 2004, Dexis Sales Materials, www.dexray.com
EVA vs. Dentrix ImageRayi
|
|
EVA |
Dentrix |
Who’s Better? |
Sensor Technology |
CMOS |
CCD |
CCD is the older technology, CMOS is the emerging technology |
|
Connection to computer |
USB |
USB |
Same technology |
|
Compatible Practice Management Software |
22 major practice management packages plus 6 imaging packages |
Dentrix only |
If you ever leave Dentrix in the future, your investment in hardware is wasted |
|
Sensor #1 Dimensions |
24 x 36 x 4.75 mm |
25.1 x 39.6 mm |
Dentrix is much larger and more difficult to position |
|
Sensor #1 Active Area |
20 x 30 mm |
20 x 30 mm |
Identical |
|
Sensor #2 Dimensions |
30 x 42 x 4.75 mm |
30.5 x 42.5 mm |
Virtually identical |
|
Sensor #2 Active Area |
26 x 36 mm |
25.6 x 36.1 mm |
Virtually identical |
|
Sensor Resolution |
16.6 lp/mm actual and theoretical |
11 lp/mm actual, 22 lp/mm theoretical |
Many systems advertise a high “theoretical” resolution when actual measured resolution
is substantially lower |
|
Suggested Retail Prices: |
|
|
|
|
Sensor #1 |
$6200 |
$7695 |
You’ll pay as much for Dentrix’s software and name as you will for an entire EVA System. Plus, consider the long-term costs of their support and upgrade fees. |
|
Sensor #2 |
$6200 |
$8695 |
|
RINN Holder Set |
$100 |
$131 |
|
Docking Station |
$140 |
$1000 |
|
Software |
$995, included for free when purchasing package |
$6195-$8395 |
|
Training |
Included |
$995/day |
|
Software Upgrades |
Free for life |
$1895/year |
|
Technical Support |
Free for life |
$1895/year |
|
Warranty |
3 years hardware, unlimited software |
2 years hardware, 90 days software |
|
Cost For Complete One-Operatory Installation |
$7200 with #1 sensor
$7200 with #2 sensor |
$12090 with #1 sensor and basic x-ray only software
$13090 with #2 sensor and basic x-ray only software |
Sources: Dentrix brochures, Dentistry
Today May 2004 Buyer’s Guide, www.dentrix.com
|